Cushion Cut Vs. Princess Cut Diamond: Pros and Cons

There are many hiccups and headaches when choosing the right shape for a diamond or engagement ring, which is a key factor in determining how your ring will look. This headache and these hiccups can cause you many problems when deciding between two popular choices: the cushion cut and the princess cut. Both have unique characteristics that make them stand out but also have advantages and drawbacks.

This guide will break down everything you need about cushion cut and princess cut diamonds, from their look and sparkle to their durability and cost. By the end, you will have a clearer idea of which one might be the best fit for you.

What is a Cushion Cut Diamond?

The cushion cut diamond is a classic shape that has been around for nearly 200 years. It's known for its soft, rounded corners and larger facets, which give it a vintage and romantic look.

Cushion cut diamonds are also known to have a pillow-shaped appearance, which is where the name comes from. A cushion cut diamond typically has a square or rectangular outline, but what sets it apart is its rounded corners. This shape combines the old mine cut (a predecessor to the modern round brilliant) and the oval cut.

The cushion cut features larger facets, which are the flat surfaces on the diamond that reflect light. These larger facets create a unique visual effect known as the "crushed ice" appearance, where light scatters in a way that gives the diamond a soft, romantic glow. These diamonds are versatile and work well in various settings, from solitaire rings to halo settings.

What is a Princess Cut Diamond?

The princess cut diamond is a modern, striking diamond shape that was first developed in the 1980s. It's known for its sharp, angular corners and brilliant faceting pattern, which create exceptional sparkle and fire. The princess cut is the second most popular diamond shape after the round brilliant, and it's a favorite for engagement rings due to its contemporary look and ability to stand out.

Princess cut diamonds are square or rectangular, with pointed corners and a flat table. Unlike the cushion cut with rounded edges, the princess cut is all about clean lines and geometric precision. The cut features a unique faceting pattern, typically with 50 to 58 facets arranged to maximize light reflection and create intense brilliance.

One of the standout features of the princess cut is its ability to appear larger than other diamond shapes of the same carat weight. This is due to its deep cut, which allows more of the diamond's weight to be concentrated in its face-up size.

Key Differences Between Cushion Cut and Princess Cut Diamonds

1. Shape & Aesthetic Appeal

The most obvious difference between cushion cut and princess cut diamonds is their shape. Cushion cut diamonds have rounded corners and a softer, more romantic look. They often have a vintage feel, making them a great choice for those who love classic or antique-inspired jewelry.

On the other hand, princess cut diamonds have sharp, angular corners and a more modern geometric look. They are sleek and bold, appealing to those who prefer a contemporary style.

2. Sparkle & Brilliance

When it comes to sparkle, both cuts have their strengths. Cushion cut diamonds are known for their "crushed ice" effect, where the light reflects in a way that creates a softer, more scattered sparkle. This gives them a dreamy, romantic glow.

Princess cut diamonds, however, are designed to maximize brilliance. Their faceting pattern allows them to reflect light, creating intense sparkle and fire. The princess cut might be better if you're looking for a diamond that catches the eye from every angle.

3. Durability & Practicality

Durability is important, especially if the diamond will be worn daily, like in an engagement ring. Cushion cut diamonds have rounded corners, which make them less prone to chipping or damage. This makes them a practical choice for everyday wear.

Princess cut diamonds, with their sharp corners, are more vulnerable to chipping. However, this can be mitigated by choosing a setting that protects the corners, such as a bezel or V-prong setting.

4. Price & Value

Regarding price, cushion cut diamonds are often more affordable than princess cut diamonds of the same carat weight. This is because cushion cuts retain more of the rough diamond during cutting, resulting in less waste.

Princess cut diamonds, while still relatively affordable compared to other shapes, can be slightly more expensive due to their popularity and the precision required to cut them.

Pros and Cons of Cushion Cut Diamonds

Pros

• Timeless Appeal: The cushion cut's vintage look never goes out of style.

• Versatility: Works well in various settings, from solitaire to halo designs.

• Durability: Rounded corners make it less prone to damage.

• Affordability: Often more budget-friendly than other diamond shapes.

Cons

• Less Sparkle: The "crushed ice" effect may not appeal to those who prefer intense brilliance.

• Varied Appearance: The look of a cushion cut can vary significantly depending on the cut quality.

Pros and Cons of Princess Cut Diamonds

Pros

• Maximum Sparkle: Known for their exceptional brilliance and fire.

• Modern Look: Perfect for those who prefer a modern style.

• Appears Larger: The cut can make the diamond look bigger than its actual carat weight.

Cons

• Fragile Corners: Sharp corners are more prone to chipping.

• Higher Cost: Slightly more expensive due to popularity and cutting precision.

Which One Should You Choose?

The choice between a cushion cut and a princess cut diamond is ultimately based on what you like and your lifestyle.

If you love vintage-inspired designs inspired by the old times and want a diamond with a soft, romantic glow, the cushion cut might be the right choice. It's also a great option if you want something durable and budget-friendly.

The princess cut could be the perfect fit if you want a modern, eye-catching diamond with maximum sparkle. Just be mindful of protecting the corners if you plan to wear it daily, as it is prone to chipping or scratching.

But you should try on both shapes to see which resonated most with you. After all, the diamond is the one that makes you feel happiest when you look at it.

Conclusion

Cushion cut and princess cut diamonds each have their own style. Cushion cuts have a classic, romantic look and are very durable. Princess cuts are modern, bright, and bold. By knowing the differences, pros, and cons, you can choose the one that fits your style and needs best.

Whether you pick the soft beauty of a cushion cut or the bright sparkle of a princess cut, you'll get a beautiful diamond to treasure for years.